| Role | | Year |
| Horace (Many roles) | |
| Charley Wykeham | |
| Emile De Beque | |
| Sky Masterson | |
| Jerry Biffle | |
| Dr. Downer | |
| Hajj | |
| Panisse | |
| Mr. Applegate | |
| Henry Higgins | |
| Harold Hill | |
| Tom Baxter | |
| Sid Davis | |
| Arthur | |
| J. Pierrepont Finch | |
| Pseudolus | |
| Foxy | |
| Tevye | |
| Don Quixote/Cervantes | |
| Michael | |
| Jacques Bonnard | |
| | Role | | Year |
| Chuck Baxter | |
| Purlie | |
| Mayer Rothschild | |
| Pseudolus | |
| Leading Player | |
| Cyrano de Bergerac | |
| Charlie Anderson | |
| Alfred P. Doolittle | |
| Jamie Lockhart | |
| Oscar Jaffee | |
| Sweeney Todd | |
| P. T. Barnum | |
| Pirate King | |
| Curtis Taylor Jr. | |
| Captain Billy Buck Chandler | |
| Albin | |
| Thomas Sapsea/William Cartwright | |
| Bill Snibson | |
| Phantom | |
| Cigar (Many roles) | |
| Stone | |
| | Role | | Year |
| Engineer | |
| Jelly Roll Morton | |
| Molina | |
| Georg Nowack | |
| J. Pierrepont Finch | |
| Pseudolus | |
| Billy Flynn | |
| Master of Ceremonies | |
| Noble Eggleston (Many roles) | |
| Fred Graham/Petruchio | |
| Max Bialystock | |
| J.J. Hunsecker | |
| Edna Turnblad | |
| Peter Allen | |
| Freddy Benson | |
| Frankie Valli | |
| Lieutenant Frank Cioffi | |
| Emile De Beque | |
| Billy Elliot | |
|