| Hint | Name | Life |
| French Nobleman who would bathe in the blood of his victims. His death toll is thought to be 200 to 600. | |
| The Alaskan Hunter. Would set his victims free only to hunt them down and murder them. | |
| The Gray Man, The Werewolf of Wysteria, The Brooklyn Vampire, The Boogeyman. Old man who delighted in cannibalizing his victims | |
| The Milwaukee Cannibal. Kept body parts as trophies. | |
| The infamous American serial killer. A law student who preyed on women. | |
| The BTK killer. Bind, Torture, Kill. | |
| The Acid Bath Murderer. Would dispose of victims by disolving them in acid. Would then assume their property and businesses. | |
| Nicknamed the Vampire of Sacramento. Thought he needed to drink others blood in order to prevent his own from turning to powder due to a delusioned Nazi injected poison. | |
| The Killer Clown. An outspoken Democrat who had a picture taken with Rosalynn Carter | |
| Though only thought to have killed 2 people, he became the inspiration for 'Psycho,' 'The Silence of the Lambs,' and 'The Texas Chainsaw Massacre' due to the horrific human remains | |