| Clue | Answer |
| Robin Sparkles' less successful 'artistic follow-up' | |
| Lily's high school boyfriend | |
| Lily's apartment was turned into one of these | |
| Barney was going to go here with the Peace Corps | |
| This is to Canadian women what chocolate is to American women | |
| Robin wants to hear her dad say this six-word phrase | |
| Robin's favorite hockey team | |
| Actress who plays Ted's future daughter | |
| Actor who plays Ted's future son | |
| College Marshall, Ted and Lily attended | |
| Barney believes this game show host is his biological father | |
| Robin went here after her breakup with Ted | |
| Stella's husband Tony wrote this movie | |
| Girl the 'diagonal' on the 'Hot-Crazy Scale' was named after | |
| Girl the 'zone' on the 'Hot-Crazy Scale' was named after | |
| Lily's nickname for Marshall | |
| Marshall's nickname for Lily | |
| Rib Town's owners wanted their building shaped like one of these | |
| Name of the overly chatty girl Ted once dated | |
| Barney's brother's name | |