| Hint (Before) | Players | Hint (After) |
| His record of 755 career Home Runs stood for 33 years | |
| 4x All-Star traded to the Miami Heat in exchange for Shaquille O'Neal | |
| Current Indianapolis Colts WR with 5 straight 1000-yard seasons | |
| Current Red Sox outfielder. Was named 2008 All-Star Game MVP | |
| Holds NFL record with 14 Interceptions in 1 season | |
| NFL 2008 Offensive Rookie of the Year | |
| All-time leading rusher for Tennessee Titans/Houston Oilers | |
| Only Detroit Pistons' player to be a member of the 2008 USA Olympic Team | |
| Hockey HOF Goalie who ranks 2nd All-time in wins | |
| Rushed for over 1000 yards in each of his first 10 seasons. 4th all-time in rushing yards. | |
| HOF Pitcher ranking 3rd all-time in Wins and 2nd All-time in Shutouts | |
| Current Boston Celtics SG and 9-time NBA All-Star | |
| Given the nickname 'Flash' by Shaquille O'Neal | |
| 2009 NL Manager of the Year winner | |
| Cincinnati Bengals all-time leader in Passing Yards and Passing TDs | |
| Baseball HOF-er partially known for the Pine Tar Incident | |
| The last NL player to hit over .400 in a season. | |
| Led NBA in assists and steals in 2007 and 2008. | |
| Pitched a perfect game in 1994 for the Texas Rangers | |