Best MLB Players not in the Hall of Fame by Wins Above Replacement Quiz by kps7179

Can you name the Best MLB Players not in the Hall of Fame by Wins Above Replacement?

created by kps7179

Enter a Player in the box below
Correctly named Players will show up below
Answers do not have to be guessed in order
Source: Baseball Reference
Active Players, or players who have not been retired for 5 or more seasons, are not included.
This quiz has not been verified by Sporcle

Popular trivia games today

'#' Movies by Picture

6291

Shortest Country Name per Letter

6117

Color Sequence Memory Game

3177

True or False Logic Quiz

2026

Word Ladder: Here's Johnny

1913

Big Adjectives

1827

Clickable 1-100 Mines

1676

Missing Word: 3-Letter Movie Words

1523

And more...

PLAY GAME

10:00

Show Missed Answers

Career Span/Primary Team(s)	Player	Wins Above Replacement
1986-2007/Pirates, Giants		178.3
1984-2007/Red Sox, Blue Jays, Yankees, Astros		133.9
1991-2005/Astros		76.7
1963-1986/Reds, Phillies, Expos		76.7
1988-2007/Orioles, Phillies, Diamondbacks, Red Sox		76.1
1878-1887/Blues, Cubs		72.7
1977-1995/Tigers		71.4
1891-1911/Cubs, Dodgers, Giants		70.9
1989-2005/Expos, Rockies		69.7
1970-1986/Orioles, Angels		67.3
1977-1996/Tigers		67.1
1979-2002/Expos, White Sox, Yankees		66.2
1972-1991/Cubs, Pirates, Giants		66.2
1986-2005/Cubs, Rangers, Orioles		66.1
1991-2007/Indians		64.9
1987-2004/Mariners		64.4
1986-2005/Rangers, Marlins, Dodgers, Yankees		64.3
1975-1992/Yankees		63.0
1972-1991/Red Sox		62.8
1967-1988/Twins, Indians, Yankees, Padres		62.8
1964-1982/Indians, Red Sox, Yankees		62.3
1988-2007/Astros		62.1
1972-1989/Indians, Rangers, Reds		61.6
1881-1894/Red Stockings (CIN)		61.5
1966-1982/Red Sox, Cardinals, Dodgers		60.8

Career Span/Primary Team(s)	Player	Wins Above Replacement
1874-1884/Red Stockings (BSN)		60.7
1908-1920/Naps, White Sox		59.6
1986-2003/Mets, Royals, Blue Jays, Yankees		58.8
1879-1895/Blues, Hoosiers, Giants, Pirates		58.8
1871-1887/Mutuals, A's		58.8
1955-1969/Cardinals		58.7
1884-1892/Cardinals, Dodgers		58.7
1986-2001/A's, Cardinals		58.7
1882-1892/Blues, Phillies		57.9
1927-1941/Indians, Red Sox		57.2
1966-1981/A's, Brewers		57.1
1974-1990/Cardinals, Mets		57.1
1960-1979/Dodgers		56.8
1963-1989/Dodgers, Yankees, Angels		56.3
1992-2007/Dodgers, Mets		56.1
1984-2001/Royals, Mets, Red Sox		56.0
1904-1919/Phillies, Red Stockings (BSN), Reds		55.8
1968-1981/Giants, Angels		55.7
1963-1977/Phillies, White Sox		55.6
1969-1989/Braves, Giants, Tigers		55.1
1916-1928/Yankees, Browns		54.9
1989-2007/White Sox, Cubs		54.8
1905-1920/Red Sox, White Sox		54.5
1960-1977/Braves, Cardinals, Mets		54.2
1986-2002/Angels, Indians		53.7

Javascript is not currently enabled on your browser.
If you do have Javascript enabled:
This site uses javascript to make the magic happen.
Please turn on javascript and reload this page, or use a more current browser (like Firefox)

You might also like these games:
MLB #1 Draft Picks	MLB Win Leaders by Team	MLB Entire Career with One Team

There are 8 comments for this game.
(Warning: comments may contain spoilers)

Top 50 MLB Players not in the Hall of Fame Quiz

by kps7179

Created Feb 6, 2013 in Sports
Game Plays 949

Friend Scores and Standings

Loading friend results....

Top Games Today in Sports

Top Games with Similar Tags

Top User Games in Sports

	soxnut23:	Feb 6th, 2013 at 17:37 GMT		-1 points
	kenny lofton played for a lot more than just one team. piazza played for the a's. I'm sure there are others with the same situation. it really throws you off when not all teams are included. either name the team they played most for or all of them

	herrod54:	Feb 7th, 2013 at 05:34 GMT		-3 points
	This is why I don't like WAR to judge a player's true worth. Where's Don Mattingly? Lee Smith?

	JakeThe:	Feb 7th, 2013 at 13:19 GMT		-2 points
	WAR is supposed to have a person's whole career but, Don Mattingly & Dwight "Doc" Gooden & Jack Morris, didn't make the top 50 list?, they were all great during the 80's

	kps7179:	Feb 7th, 2013 at 14:51 GMT		0 points
	Dwight Gooden was great for a couple years but cocaine destroyed the rest. Mattingly and Morris are eminently overrated, in my opinion.

	kidcanada:	Feb 7th, 2013 at 16:23 GMT		3 points
	@herrod54 - Mattingly had about 4 great years and that's about it. Small peak. Same for Dale Murphy. Lee Smith is a closer, whose value is wildly overvalued. Bruce Sutter being in the HOF is a joke. Eckersley belongs, Gossage belongs, Rivera will belong, that's probably it.

	kidcanada:	Feb 7th, 2013 at 16:25 GMT		3 points
	@JakeThe - Mattingly had 4 good years. Gooden even less. Jack Morris had a career ERA of 3.90, which would be the highest of any pitcher in the HOF by a mile. Was he a better pitcher than Dave Stieb, Dennis Martinez or Mark Langston? Not really. Even his playoff ERA was only 3.80. Never finished higher than 3rd in Cy Young voting so it's not like even then he was perceived as some dominant pitching machine.

	NickD:	Feb 7th, 2013 at 17:12 GMT		-1 points
	Lofton should at least have a couple teams added, otherwise it makes it seem like he played for the Indians his whole career

	kps7179:	Feb 7th, 2013 at 18:57 GMT		0 points
	Kenny Lofton played 10 seasons with the Indians. He spent 1 season (or part of 1 season) each with the Astros, Braves, White Sox, Giants, Pirates, Cubs, Yankees, Phillies, Dodgers and Rangers, finishing up his career with the Indians. I labeled the category "Primary Team(s)". The only one that qualifies are the Indians.