Top 50 MLB Players not in the Hall of Fame

Random Sports or MLB Quiz

Can you name the Best MLB Players not in the Hall of Fame by Wins Above Replacement?

Quiz not verified by Sporcle

How to Play
Score 0/50 Timer 10:00
Career Span/Primary Team(s)PlayerWins Above Replacement
1986-2007/Pirates, Giants178.3
1984-2007/Red Sox, Blue Jays, Yankees, Astros133.9
1991-2005/Astros76.7
1963-1986/Reds, Phillies, Expos76.7
1988-2007/Orioles, Phillies, Diamondbacks, Red Sox76.1
1878-1887/Blues, Cubs72.7
1977-1995/Tigers71.4
1891-1911/Cubs, Dodgers, Giants70.9
1989-2005/Expos, Rockies69.7
1970-1986/Orioles, Angels67.3
1977-1996/Tigers67.1
1979-2002/Expos, White Sox, Yankees66.2
1972-1991/Cubs, Pirates, Giants66.2
1986-2005/Cubs, Rangers, Orioles66.1
1991-2007/Indians64.9
1987-2004/Mariners64.4
1986-2005/Rangers, Marlins, Dodgers, Yankees64.3
1975-1992/Yankees63.0
1972-1991/Red Sox62.8
1967-1988/Twins, Indians, Yankees, Padres62.8
1964-1982/Indians, Red Sox, Yankees62.3
1988-2007/Astros62.1
1972-1989/Indians, Rangers, Reds61.6
1881-1894/Red Stockings (CIN)61.5
1966-1982/Red Sox, Cardinals, Dodgers60.8
Career Span/Primary Team(s)PlayerWins Above Replacement
1874-1884/Red Stockings (BSN)60.7
1908-1920/Naps, White Sox59.6
1986-2003/Mets, Royals, Blue Jays, Yankees58.8
1879-1895/Blues, Hoosiers, Giants, Pirates58.8
1871-1887/Mutuals, A's58.8
1955-1969/Cardinals58.7
1884-1892/Cardinals, Dodgers58.7
1986-2001/A's, Cardinals58.7
1882-1892/Blues, Phillies57.9
1927-1941/Indians, Red Sox57.2
1966-1981/A's, Brewers57.1
1974-1990/Cardinals, Mets57.1
1960-1979/Dodgers56.8
1963-1989/Dodgers, Yankees, Angels56.3
1992-2007/Dodgers, Mets56.1
1984-2001/Royals, Mets, Red Sox56.0
1904-1919/Phillies, Red Stockings (BSN), Reds55.8
1968-1981/Giants, Angels55.7
1963-1977/Phillies, White Sox55.6
1969-1989/Braves, Giants, Tigers55.1
1916-1928/Yankees, Browns54.9
1989-2007/White Sox, Cubs54.8
1905-1920/Red Sox, White Sox54.5
1960-1977/Braves, Cardinals, Mets54.2
1986-2002/Angels, Indians53.7

Friend Scores


  Player Best Score Plays Last Played
You You haven't played this game yet.

You Might Also Like...

Extras