| Clue | Answer | Letter |
| The name of the vessel Lucifer inhabits for the majority of Season 5 | |
| Episode where Dean tortures Alastair and discovers the truth about the first seal | |
| Blind psychic who calls Sam 'grumpy' | |
| This band (who fits the the letter) has a song called 'Bang Your Head' which is heard in the episonde 'Hookman' | |
| Archangel trapped in a circle of burning oil, by Castiel and Dean, in 'Free to Be You and Me' | |
| He made a gun that they say can kill anything | |
| Episode where Dean shares a deep dish pizza with Death | |
| 'The funniest angel in the garrison' | |
| Obsessed FBI agent who compares Sam and Dean to Bonnie and Clyde | |
| This Biblical baddie is one of the signs of the apocalypse. Sam and Dean think she's a prophet until Castiel enlightens them. | |
| In 'The Usual Suspects' Dean asks, 'So Scully... what do ya think? '. This is a reference to which show? | |
| Episode where Dean nearly dies of fright | |
| Angel who will stop at nothing to make Dean say yes to Michael. Dean kills him. | |