| Game | Leading Scorer | Points |
| 1975 Kentucky vs. UCLA | |
| 1974 Marquette vs. North Carolina St. | |
| 1973 Memphis vs. UCLA | |
| 1972 Florida State vs. UCLA | |
| 1971 UCLA vs. Villanova | |
| 1970 Jacksonville vs. UCLA | |
| 1969 Purdue vs. UCLA | |
| 1968 North Carolina vs. UCLA | |
| 1967 Dayton vs. UCLA | |
| 1966 Kentucky vs. UTEP | |
| 1965 Michigan vs. UCLA | |
| 1964 Duke vs. UCLA | |
| 1963 Cincinnati vs. Loyola | |
| 1962 Cincinnati vs. Ohio State | |
| 1961 Cincinnati vs. Ohio State | |
| 1960 California vs. Ohio State | |
| 1959 California vs. West Virginia | |
| 1958 Kentucky vs. Seattle | |
| 1957 Kansas vs. North Carolina | |
| 1956 Iowa vs. San Francisco | |
| 1955 LaSalle vs. San Francisco | |
| 1954 Bradley vs. LaSalle | |
| 1953 Indiana vs. Kansas | |
| 1952 Kansas vs. St. John's | |
| 1951 Kansas State vs. Kentucky | |
| 1950 Bradley vs. CCNY | |
| 1949 Kentucky vs. Oklahoma State | |
| 1948 Baylor vs. Kentucky | |
| 1947 Holy Cross vs. Oklahoma | |
| 1946 North Carolina vs. Oklahoma St. | |
| 1945 NYU vs. Oklahoma State | |
| 1944 Dartmouth vs. Utah | |
| 1943 Georgetown vs. Wyoming | |
| 1942 Dartmouth vs. Stanford | |
| 1941 Washington State vs. Wisconsin | |
| 1940 Indiana vs. Kansas | |
| 1939 Ohio State vs. Oregon | |