| Identity/hint | The Bat-Villains |
| The Clown prince of crime | |
| Oswald Chesterfield Cobblepot | |
| Selina Kyle | |
| Harvey Dent | |
| Edward Nygma | |
| Dr. Victor Fries | |
| Prof. Jonathan Crane | |
| Pamela Isley | |
| Dorrance (Back Breaker) | |
| Leader of the League of Shadows | |
| Jervis Tetch | |
| Basil Karlo | |
| Drury Walker | |
| Dr. Harleen Quinzel | |
| Waylon Jones | |
| | Identity/hint | The Bat-Villains |
| Dr. Thomas Elliot | |
| Roman Sionis | |
| Julian Day | |
| Thomas Blake | |
| Floyd Lawton | |
| Garfield Lynns | |
| Prof. worked at Arkham is very odd | |
| Dr. Kirk Langstrom | |
| Alias of Original joker/now Jason Todd | |
| Dumfee and Deever Tweed | |
| Arnold Wesker | |
| Serial Killer /tally marks on himself | |
| Mother of Damien Wayne | |
| Killed Thomas and Martha Wayne | |
| Dr. Karl Hellfurn | |
| Vampire | |
| Charles Brown | |
| DC's #1 Asassin | |
| Alien/goody goody (yet insanely awesome) | |
|