| Most Anthologized Poem | Poet | Lifespan |
| General Prologue to The Canterbury Tales | |
| To Mistress Margaret Hussey | |
| They Flee from Me That Sometime Did Me Seek | |
| The Nymph's Reply to the Shepherd | |
| One Day I Wrote Her Name upon the Strand | |
| With How Sad Steps, O Moon, Thou Climb'st the Skies! | |
| His Golden Locks Time Hath to Silver Turned (A Farewell to Arms) | |
| The Burning Babe | |
| Care-Charmer Sleep, Son of the Sable Night | |
| Since There's No Help, Come Let Us Kiss and Part | |
| The Passionate Shepherd to His Love | |
| That Time of Year Thou Mayst in Me Behold | |
| My Sweetest Lesbia | |
| Adieu, Farewell, Earth's Bliss | |
| Tichborne's Elegy | |
| On His Mistress, the Queen of Bohemia | |
| Death, Be Not Proud | |
| Drink to Me Only with Thine Eyes | |
| Call for the Robin Redbreast and the Wren | |
| On the Countess Dowager of Pembroke | |
| To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time | |
| Exequy on His Wife | |
| Love Bade Me Welcome | |
| Ask Me No More Where Jove Bestows | |
| The Lark Now Leaves His Watery Nest | |
| Go, Lovely Rose | |
| Lycidas | |
| Why So Pale and Wan, Fond Lover? | |
| | Most Anthologized Poem | Poet | Lifespan |
| To My Dear and Loving Husband | |
| To Lucasta, Going to the Wars | |
| To His Coy Mistress | |
| The Retreat | |
| To the Memory of Mr. Oldham | |
| Huswifery | |
| A Description of the Morning | |
| Know Then Thyself | |
| A Short Song of Congratulation | |
| Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard | |
| Ode to Evening | |
| When Lovely Woman Stoops to Folly | |
| Light Shining out of Darkness | |
| The Indian Burying Ground | |
| The Tiger | |
| A Red, Red Rose | |
| The World Is Too Much With Us | |
| Proud Maisie | |
| Kubla Khan | |
| The Battle of Blenheim | |
| Rose Aylmer | |
| Hohenlinden | |
| A Visit from St. Nicholas | |
| Jenny Kissed Me | |
| So We'll Go No More a-Roving | |
| The Burial of Sir John Moore after Corunna | |
| Ozymandias | |
| I Am | |
| | Most Anthologized Poem | Poet | Lifespan |
| To a Waterfowl | |
| To Autumn | |
| I Remember, I Remember | |
| Old Adam, the Carrion Crow | |
| Concord Hymn | |
| How Do I Love Thee? Let Me Count the Ways | |
| My Lost Youth | |
| Barbara Frietchie | |
| The Deacon's Masterpiece; or, The Wonderful 'One-Hoss Shay' | |
| To Helen | |
| The Splendor Falls | |
| My Last Duchess | |
| The Owl and the Pussy-Cat | |
| Remembrance | |
| Say Not the Struggle Nought Availeth | |
| The Battle Hymn of the Republic | |
| A Noiseless Patient Spider | |
| Dover Beach | |
| The Fairies | |
| Lucifer in Starlight | |
| The Blessed Damozel | |
| 'Because I could not stop for Death' | |
| When I Am Dead | |
| Jabberwocky | |
| The Yarn of the Nancy Bell | |
| When the Hounds of Spring Are on Winter's Traces | |
| The Darkling Thrush | |
| London Snow | |
| | Most Anthologized Poem | Poet | Lifespan |
| Pied Beauty | |
| Wynken, Blynken, and Nod | |
| Requiem | |
| The Man with the Hoe | |
| The Ballad of Reading Gaol | |
| Loveliest of Trees | |
| The Hound of Heaven | |
| Recessional | |
| The Second Coming | |
| The Purple Cow | |
| Non Sum Qualis Eram Bonae sub Regno Cynarae | |
| Anne Rutledge | |
| Mr. Flood's Party | |
| Leisure | |
| The Listeners | |
| Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening | |
| Cargoes | |
| Chicago | |
| The Owl | |
| Abraham Lincoln Walks at Midnight | |
| Sunday Morning | |
| The Red Wheelbarrow | |
| Piano | |
| The River Merchant's Wife: A Letter | |
| The Soldier | |
| Hurt Hawks | |
| Poetry | |
| Still Falls the Rain | |
| | Most Anthologized Poem | Poet | Lifespan |
| The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock | |
| Bells for John Whiteside's Daughter | |
| If We Must Die | |
| Break of Day in the Trenches | |
| You, Andrew Marvell | |
| Anthem for Doomed Youth | |
| anyone lived in a pretty how town | |
| To Brooklyn Bridge | |
| Ode to the Confederate Dead | |
| The Negro Speaks of Rivers | |
| Not Waving But Drowning | |
| The Fury of Aerial Bombardment | |
| Musée des Beaux Arts | |
| Bagpipe Music | |
| My Papa's Waltz | |
| I Think Continually of Those Who Were Truly Great | |
| The Fish | |
| Those Winter Sundays | |
| The Death of the Ball Turret Gunner | |
| Naming of Parts | |
| Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night | |
| We Real Cool | |
| Skunk Hour | |
| Love Calls Us to the Things of This World | |
| Church Going | |
| A Supermarket in California | |
| Daddy | |
|