| Hint | Player |
| Closer from St. John's spent 14 of his 21 MLB years with Mets | |
| Co-World Series MVP in 1981 | |
| The Cuban Comet, played in five decades, got a hit at age 50 in 1976 | |
| Yankees 2B whose father pitched for the Astros in the 1970s | |
| The National League's Gold Glove 3B in 2011 | |
| Broke up Bill Bevans' no-hit bid in the 1947 World Series | |
| The Reading Rifle was strong-armed RF for Dodgers in the 1950s | |
| Indians power hitter who was traded for Harvey Kuenn prior to 1960 season | |
| Dodger catcher who was hit in head with bat by Juan Marichal | |
| A's 3B was runner-up for AL MVP in 1971 | |
| Reds CF was 3,000th strikeout victim of both Ryan and Gibson | |
| Slugger had 3,000 hits and 500 HRs and last played in 2005 with Orioles | |
| Won 125 games for Cubs from 2001-11 | |
| Braves 2B was named to All-Star team in 2010 | |
| Cubs SS had 207 hits in 2011 | |
| Brewers pitcher has had 200 or more strikeouts in 2009, 10 and 11 | |