| Hint | Production |
| This production began life in 1997 as a 20-minute program for the 50th birthday celebration of Elton John before being mounted as a full scale touring and Broadway production | |
| Featuring two of Hollywood's most sought after leading men, this play about two cops did boffo business at the Schoenfeld Theatre | |
| Playwright Tracy Letts returned to Broadway following his 2007 hit August: Osage County with this play set in a small donut shop in Chicago | |
| Carrie Fisher made her return to Broadway with this, her one woman show, which shares the title of her 2008 autobiography | |
| London's Donmar Warehouse transferred their West End production of this classic Shakespearean tragedy with Jude Law once again starring as the title character | |
| Manhattan Theatre Club produced the revival of this Kaufman and Ferber comedy about a family of performers | |
| Bill Pullman and Julia Stiles headlined this production by David Mamet | |
| The cast of the Roundabout Theatre production of this musical continued to 'put on a happy face' for 117 performances despite their mostly negative reviews | |
| This new musical had out-of-town tryouts at the La Jolla Playhouse and Seattle's 5th Avenue Theatre before making its way to the Shubert Theatre | |
| Roundabout Theatre Company produced this new work by Patrick Marber, a version of Strindberg's Miss Julie | |
| The revival of this Neil Simon classic shuttered after only nine regular performances | |
| After a successful Encores! production, this musical brought Rainbow Valley to the historic St. James Theatre | |
| The revival of this 1990's musical had a devoted fan base but failed to find commercial success, closing after only 65 regular performances | |
| In early November the Lyceum Theatre welcomed this 'stimulating' new comedy by Sarah Ruhl | |
| Following a successful run during the 2008-2009 season, this musical once more returned to the Marquis Theatre for the 2009 holiday season | |
| Bill T. Jones conceived, directed, and choreographed this new musical, which had a successful Off-Broadway debut at 37 Arts | |
| A quartet of Hollywood veterans brought to life this new work by David Mamet | |
| This play by Neil Simon was originally scheduled to play in repertory with another Neil Simon classic, but was cancelled due to disappointing ticket sales | |
| After a successful run at London's Menier Chocolate Factory, this musical found its way to the Walter Kerr Theatre with star Catherine Zeta Jones making her Broadway debut | |
| Roundabout Theatre Company revived this three-act, 1940's comedy about a former matinee idol | |
| The revival of this Arthur Miller drama did standing room only business at the Cort Theatre thanks to the Broadway debut of one of Hollywood's A-list starlets | |