| Winning Team | Losing Team | Year |
| Navy | |
| Cleveland State | |
| Arkansas-Little Rock | |
| Xavier | |
| Missouri State | |
| Austin Peay | |
| Murray State | |
| Richmond | |
| Middle Tennessee | |
| Siena | |
| Northern Iowa | |
| Xavier | |
| Penn State | |
| Richmond | |
| East Tennessee State | |
| Louisiana-Lafayette | |
| Southern | |
| Santa Clara | |
| Manhattan | |
| Weber State | |
| Old Dominion | |
| Princeton | |
| | Winning Team | Losing Team | Year |
| Coppin State | |
| Chattanooga | |
| Richmond | |
| Valparaiso | |
| Oklahoma | |
| Weber State | |
| Indiana State | |
| Kent State | |
| Hampton | |
| UNC Wilmington | |
| Tulsa | |
| Bucknell | |
| Vermont | |
| Northwestern State | |
| Bradley | |
| Siena | |
| San Diego | |
| Cleveland State | |
| Ohio | |
| Murray State | |
| Morehead State | |
|