| '2005 Team' | Player | Rating |
| Chicago Bears (C) | |
| Cincinnatti Bengals (WR) | |
| Buffalo Bills (ROLB) | |
| Denver Broncos (CB) | |
| Cleaveland Browns (QB) | |
| Tampa Bay Buccaneers (ROLB) | |
| Arizona Cardinals (P) | |
| San Diego Chargers (RB) | |
| Kansas City Chiefs (TE) | |
| Indiapolis Colts (K) | |
| Dallas Cowboys (DT) | |
| Miami Dolphins (RE) | |
| Philadelphia Eagles (FS) | |
| Atlanta Falcons (ROLB) | |
| San Francisco 49ers (LOLB) | |
| New York Giants (LE) | |
| Jacksonville Jaguars (DT) | |
| | '2005 Team' | Player | Rating |
| New York Jets (C) | |
| Detroit Lions (LG) | |
| Green Bay Packers (SS) | |
| Carolina Panthers (P) | |
| New England Patriots (CB) | |
| Oakland Raiders (P) | |
| St. Louis Rams (LT) | |
| Baltimore Ravens (LT) | |
| Washington Redskins (ROLB) | |
| New Orleans Saints (RB) | |
| Seattle Seahawks (LT) | |
| Pittsburgh Steelers (LG) | |
| Houston Texans (CB) | |
| Tennessee Titans (QB) | |
| MInnesota Vikings (WR) | |
| Free Agents (LOLB) | |
|