| Nickname | Superstar | Hint |
| The 8th Wonder of the World | |
| The 9th Wonder of the World | |
| A-List | |
| The All-American American | |
| The American Dream | |
| The Animal | |
| The Anvil | |
| The Apex Predator | |
| The Ayatollah of Rock and Rolla | |
| The Barber | |
| Big Daddy Cool | |
| Big Poppa Pump | |
| The Big Red Machine | |
| The Billion Dollar Princess | |
| The Birdman | |
| The Bizarre One | |
| The Body | |
| Captain Charisma | |
| The Celtic Warrior | |
| The Charismatic Enigma | |
| The Chosen One | |
| Dashing | |
| Deadman | |
| The Derranged One | |
| The Dirtiest Player in the Game | |
| | Nickname | Superstar | Hint |
| The Doctor of Thuganomics | |
| Dr. Death | |
| The Dragon | |
| The Excellence of Excecution | |
| The Funkasaurus | |
| The Game | |
| The Glamazon | |
| The Gold Standard | |
| The Great One | |
| Hacksaw | |
| The Hammer | |
| The Heartbreak Kid | |
| The Houdini of Hardcore | |
| The Immortal | |
| The Japanese Buzzsaw | |
| The King | |
| Latino Heat | |
| The Long Island Iced-Z | |
| The Loose Cannon | |
| The Mancho Man | |
| The Masterpiece | |
| The Mexican Aristocrat | |
| The Million Dollar Man | |
| The Model | |
| The Mouth of the South | |
| | Nickname | Superstar | Hint |
| The Moscow Mauler | |
| Mr. Monday Night | |
| Mr. Perfect | |
| Mr. USA | |
| Mr. Wonderful | |
| The One Man Southern Rock Band | |
| The Paparazzi Diva | |
| The Punjabi Nightmare | |
| The Rabid Wolverine | |
| Ravishing | |
| The Samoan Bulldozer | |
| The Sensai of Mattitude | |
| The Shaman of Sexy | |
| The Snake | |
| The Straight Edge Superstar | |
| Superfly | |
| Superstar | |
| The Texas Rattlesnake | |
| Too Sexy | |
| The Ultimate Opportunist | |
| The Weasel | |
| The World's Largest Athlete | |
| The World's Largest Love Machine | |
| The World's Strongest Man | |
| Your Olympic Hero | |
|