| Team(s) | Manager | # of appearances |
| ATL, NYY, LAD | |
| TOR, ATL | |
| CHW, OAK, STL | |
| NYY | |
| CHI-C, NYY | |
| NYG | |
| PHA | |
| CIN, SEA, CHC | |
| BRO, LAD | |
| LAD | |
| CIN, DET | |
| BAL | |
| LAA | |
| NYY | |
| KCR, STL | |
| PIT | |
| MIN | |
| CLE | |
| BOS, OAK, SD | |
| NYM, CIN | |
| PIT, FLA, DET | |
| BOS | |
| MIN, DET, NYY, OAK | |
| HOU | |
| PIT, STL, CIN | |
| | Team(s) | Manager | # of appearances |
| NYY, KCR | |
| PHI | |
| STL, BOS-N | |
| SD | |
| SF, CHC | |
| TOR | |
| CHC | |
| SF, OAK | |
| WSH, NYY | |
| BRO, NYG | |
| CHC | |
| PIT, HOU | |
| NYY | |
| OAK | |
| TEX | |
| PHI | |
| DET | |
| NYG | |
| HOU | |
| STL | |
| CAL, PHI | |
| CAL | |
| PHI | |
| CHW | |
| MIL-N | |
| | Team(s) | Manager | # of appearances |
| CIN, BOS | |
| BRO | |
| WSH, BOS | |
| SF | |
| TOR, BOS | |
| DET | |
| NYM | |
| PIT | |
| OAK | |
| PHN, CIN | |
| BOS | |
| BOS | |
| ARI | |
| CLE, CHW | |
| LAD, COL | |
| BOS | |
| NYY, NYM | |
| BRO | |
| NYY, ARI | |
| NYY | |
| BRO | |
| MIN | |
| STL | |
| KCR, CHC | |
|