| Year, Team | Player | PA |
| 2007 Phillies | |
| 1993 Phillies | |
| 1974 Reds | |
| 1975 Phillies | |
| 2007 Mets | |
| 1975 Reds | |
| 2008 Mets | |
| 2004 Mariners | |
| 1976 Reds | |
| 1962 Dodgers | |
| 2006 Phillies | |
| 1985 Red Sox | |
| 1979 Pirates | |
| | Year, Team | Player | PA |
| 1965 Reds | |
| 1938 Yankees | |
| 1948 Red Sox | |
| 1930 Cubs | |
| 1962 Yankees | |
| 2006 Mariners | |
| 2005 Yankees | |
| 1996 Red Sox | |
| 1973 Reds | |
| 1928 Cardinals | |
| 2006 Indians | |
| 1982 Brewers | |
| 2006 Cubs | |
|