| Series | Player | HR |
| 2009 WS (PHI/NYY) | |
| 2010 ALCS (NYY/TEX) | |
| 2010 ALCS (NYY/TEX) | |
| 2008 ALCS (BOS/TBR) | |
| 2008 ALCS (BOS/TBR) | |
| 2004 NLCS (HOU/STL) | |
| 2004 NLCS (HOU/STL) | |
| 2004 NLDS (ATL/HOU) | |
| 2002 WS (ANA/SFG) | |
| 2010 NLCS (PHI/SFG) | |
| 2010 ALDS (TBR/TEX) | |
| 2010 ALDS (TBR/TEX) | |
| 2009 WS (PHI/NYY) | |
| 2009 ALCS (LAA/NYY) | |
| 2009 NLCS (LAD/PHI) | |
| 2008 WS (PHI/TBR) | |
| 2008 ALCS (BOS/TBR) | |
| 2008 ALCS (BOS/TBR) | |
| 2008 ALDS (CHW/TBR) | |
| 2007 ALCS (BOS/CLE) | |
| | Series | Player | HR |
| 2006 NLCS (NYM/STL) | |
| 2006 NLCS (NYM/STL) | |
| 2005 ALDS (LAA/NYY) | |
| 2004 ALCS (BOS/NYY) | |
| 2004 NLCS (HOU/STL) | |
| 2004 NLCS (HOU/STL) | |
| 2004 NLCS (HOU/STL) | |
| 2004 NLDS (LAD/STL) | |
| 2003 ALCS (BOS/NYY) | |
| 2003 ALCS (BOS/NYY) | |
| 2003 NLCS (CHC/FLA) | |
| 2003 NLCS (CHC/FLA) | |
| 2003 ALDS (BOS/OAK) | |
| 2002 WS (ANA/SFG) | |
| 2002 WS (ANA/SFG) | |
| 2002 ALCS (ANA/MIN) | |
| 2002 ALDS (ANA/NYY) | |
| 2002 NLDS (ATL/SFG) | |
| 2001 ALCS (NYY/SEA) | |
|