| Hint | Answer |
| Played 140 games at second base for the 1953 Cardinals | |
| Played 146 games shortstop for the 1950 Red Sox | |
| Played 144 games at first base for the 1955 Senators | |
| Caught 115 games for the 1957 Reds | |
| Played 144 games at first base for the 1955 Athletics | |
| Pitched 255 2/3 innings for the 1959 White Sox | |
| Played 154 games at third base for the 1953 Indians | |
| Pitched 224 1/3 innings for the 1959 Pirates | |
| | Hint | Answer |
| Played 151 games in left field for the 1952 Cubs | |
| Played 147 games at first base for the 1958 Giants | |
| Pitched 179 2/3 innings for the 1956 Yankees | |
| Played 152 games in center field for the 1958 Phillies | |
| Played 141 games at shortstop for the 1956 Tigers | |
| Caugh 132 games for the 1958 Orioles | |
| Played 154 games at first base for the 1954 Dodgers | |
| Pitched 271 innings for the 1957 Braves | |
|