| Hint | Character | Actor |
| Partial Owner of Paddy's Pub, Attended UPenn | |
| Partial Owner of Paddy's Pub, Creator of Night Man | |
| Partial Owner of Paddy's Pub, once suspected of being a serial killer | |
| Bartender at Paddy's Pub, Dropped out of UPenn as a psych major | |
| Father of two members of 'the gang,' often bails the group out of tight situations with his money | |
| Coffee Shop employee crush of one of the guys | |
| Priest turned homeless | |
| Actress friend of the gang, auditions for bar dancer and is stage manager for the production of 'The Nightman Cometh' | |
| Estranged twin, middle school acquaintance of the gang | |
| | Hint | Character | Actor |
| Estranged twin, middle school acquaintance of the gang | |
| Sister of the estranged twins | |
| Mother of one of the guys, the 'Bang Maid' | |
| Convict who runs a prison heroin ring | |
| Wealthy mother of two of the main characters, dies in a botched plastic surgery operation | |
| Chain smoking wife of prison convict and mother of one of the members of the gang | |
| Philanthropist blood father of two of the main characters | |
| Transvestite with whom one of the guys has a relationship | |
| Everyone's favorite spandex mascot | |
|