| Victim | Murder |
| Henry Dunn | |
| Christopher 'Sully' Sullivan | |
| Danny Brooks | |
| Malcolm Ross | |
| 'Uncle' Marty Dunn | |
| Catherine Wellington | |
| Thomas Wellington | |
| Trish Wellington | |
| Cousin Ben | |
| Beth Barrington | |
| Lucy Daramour | |
| Chloe Carter | |
| Cal Vandeusen | |
| John Wakefield | |
| Hunter Jennings | |
| | Victim | Murder |
| Joel Booth | |
| Shane Pierce | |
| J.D. Dunn | |
| Richard Allen | |
| Kelly Seaver | |
| Nikki Bolton | |
| Maggie Krell | |
| Charlie 'Sheriff' Mills | |
| Cole Harkin | |
| Deputy Lillis | |
| Reverend Fain | |
| Deputy Garrett | |
| Officer Daryll Riggens | |
| Officer Tyra Coulter | |
|