| Good Critique | Movie | Bad Critique |
| A magnificent science-fiction film, all the more intriguing because it raises questions about the origin of human life and doesn't have the answers. [Chicago Sun-Times] | |
| Not just a reboot - it's a rejuvenation. It pulses with the warm blood of a very human hero. [St. Louis Post-Dispatch] | |
| [Movie] is a shot to the arm of pure, silly action-movie fun, and it stars so many heavy hitters it might break your brain to keep up with what's happening onscreen. [TV Guide] | |
| Depp's performance is more than just funny - it's ghoulishly endearing. [Entertainment Weekly] | |
| Though it's crude and juvenile, [movie] is versatile enough to sneak in a good shot or two at the American political system. [Miami Herald] | |
| It's a gorgeously animated children's entertainment, and an unusually astute exploration of the complex bond between mothers and daughters. [Slate] | |
| | Good Critique | Movie | Bad Critique |
| An immensely satisfying taste of antebellum empowerment packaged as spaghetti-Western homage. [Variety] | |
| When it's in full stride, the gore and silver bullets are flying and it's a kick. The title sounds like a joke, but the movie is serious fun. [Portland Oregonian] | |
| [Movie] doesn't forget it has to be an exciting spy film above all, but from its first scene, it ratchets up the drama in ways that have little to do with action. [The A.V. Club] | |
| Easily erases the second installment's vague but unpleasant memory and paves the way for future installments. [Hollywood Reporter] | |
| [Movie] aims to be a fast-paced, workmanlike sequel that shows off its charismatic leading man, and that's exactly what it does. [Arizona Republic] | |
| Walt Disney Animation Studios has a high-scoring hit on its hands in this gorgeously executed toon, earning bonus points for backing nostalgia with genuine emotion. [Variety] | |
|