| Year/Team Played For | Player |
| 1881 Trojans | |
| 1925 Yankees | |
| 1936 Reds | |
| 1950 Pirates | |
| 1952 Giants | |
| 1952 Athletics | |
| 1955 Braves | |
| 1956 Pirates | |
| 1956 Pirates | |
| 1963 Cubs | |
| 1970 Phillies | |
| 1970 Cardinals | |
| 1973 Indians | |
| 1979 Cardinals | |
| | Year/Team Played For | Player |
| 1983 Phillies | |
| 1984 Rangers | |
| 1985 Mariners | |
| 1986 Angels | |
| 1988 Tigers | |
| 1996 Orioles | |
| 2001 Pirates | |
| 2002 Yankees | |
| 2006 Reds | |
| 2010 Braves | |
| 2011 Indians | |
| 2011 Astros | |
| 2011 White Sox | |
|