| Memorable Moment | Player | Position |
| A-Rod slapped the ball out of his glove in game 6 ALCS | |
| Hit a 2-run double in game 4 WS | |
| 'Who's Your Daddy Now?' | |
| Pitched in 5 ALCS games | |
| World Series game 1 starter | |
| Caught game 1 of the world series | |
| ALCS Game 4 winning pitcher | |
| Started bench clearing brawl vs. yankees July 24 | |
| Homered in 3 straight postseason games (ALCS 6,7 & WS game 1) | |
| Replaced Nomah at SS | |
| On the mound for final out of game 7 ALCS | |
| 'Back to ____, Red Sox fans have longed to hear it...' | |
| Traded for O-Cab and Mientkiewicz | |
| | Memorable Moment | Player | Position |
| ALCS MVP | |
| Recorded final out of the WS | |
| His walk-off HR in July was the turning point of '04 season | |
| Ruben Sierra grounded out to him on the last pitch of the ALCS | |
| Homered in his first ML game on May 15 | |
| Winner of clinching games in ALDS, ALCS, WS | |
| Hit 2 HR's in game 7 ALCS | |
| Was playing RF when the red sox won the WS | |
| 'Lefty One-Out Guy' | |
| 'Dont let us win tonight!' | |
| WS MVP | |
| 'The Steal' | |
| Went 21-6 in his first season with the team | |
|