| Year / Team | Player | Age |
| 2012 / COL | |
| 2011 / BOS | |
| 2010 / PHI | |
| 2009 / PHI | |
| 2008 / PHI | |
| 2007 / NYM/ATL | |
| 2006 / NYM | |
| 2005 / ATL | |
| 2004 / ATL | |
| 2003 / SD/MIN/NYY | |
| 2002 / LAD | |
| 2001 / LAD | |
| 2000 / LAD, OAK | |
| 1999 / BAL | |
| 1998 / ATL, BOS | |
| 1997 / STL | |
| 1996 / STL | |
| 1995 / CLE | |
| 1994 / FLA | |
| 1993 / TEX | |
| 1992 / TEX | |
| 1991 / TEX | |
| 1990 / TEX | |
| 1989 / NYY | |
| 1988 / NYY | |
| 1987 / ATL/CLE/TOR | |
| 1986 / CLE | |
| | Year / Team | Player | Age |
| 1985 / NYY | |
| 1984 / NYY | |
| 1983 / STL, SEA/KC | |
| 1982 / LAD | |
| 1981 / ATL | |
| 1980 / CHW | |
| 1979 / LAD | |
| 1978 / LAD | |
| 1977 / LAD, CAL | |
| 1976 / CHW | |
| 1975 / CAL | |
| 1974 / SF | |
| 1973 / SF | |
| 1972 / LAD | |
| 1971 / LAD/ATL | |
| 1970 / ATL/CHC | |
| 1969 / ATL | |
| 1968 / CHW | |
| 1967 / CHW | |
| 1966 / CHW | |
| 1965 / KC | |
| 1964 / MIL | |
| 1963 / STL | |
| 1962 / PIT | |
| 1961 / MIL/KC | |
| 1960 / PIT | |
|