| Never Have I Ever . . . | Answer |
| . . . won an NBA Finals championship title: A. Hakeem Olajuwon | B. Larry Bird | C. Steve Nash | |
| . . . won the MLB Rookie of the Year Award: A. Jackie Robinson | B. Babe Ruth | C. Mark McGwire | |
| . . . won an Olympic gold medal as an athlete: A. Wayne Gretzky | B. Sheryl Swoopes | C. Karl Malone | |
| . . . scored a goal in an NHL game: A. Martin Brodeur | B. Patrick Roy | C. Bobby Hull | |
| . . . won the NCAA Division I Basketball Championship (men's): A. Texas Western | B. Ohio | C. Utah | |
| . . . earned a college degree: A. Carmelo Anthony | B. Joe Namath | C. Mia Hamm | |
| . . . won the Masters Tournament (golf): A. Ernie Els | B. Vijay Singh | C. Arnold Palmer | |
| . . . won a World Series: A. New York Yankees | B. New York Mets | C. Seattle Mariners | |
| . . . played for the football team at the University of Notre Dame: A. Tim Brown | B. Jay Cutler | C. Brady Quinn | |
| . . . won a Super Bowl: A. Dan Marino | B. Joe Montana | C. Peyton Manning | |
| . . . won the MLB Rookie of the Year Award: A. Jackie Robinson | B. Babe Ruth | C. Mark McGwire | |
| . . . won an Olympic gold medal as an athlete: A. Wayne Gretzky | B. Sheryl Swoopes | C. Karl Malone | |
| . . . won the U.S. Open (tennis): A. John McEnroe | B. Venus Williams | C. Caroline Wozniacki | |
| . . . lost a Super Bowl game after making it to the big game more than once: A. Cincinnati Bengals | B. Baltimore Ravens | C. San Francisco 49ers | |
| . . . won a Stanley Cup: A. Phoenix Coyotes | B. Anaheim Ducks | C. Calgary Flames | |
| . . . had Michael 'MJ' Jordan on my roster: A. Seattle Supersonics | B. Chicago Bulls | C. Washington Wizards | |
| . . . scored a goal in an NHL game: A. Martin Brodeur | B. Patrick Roy | C. Bobby Hull | |
| . . . won a FIFA World Cup (men's soccer): A. Uruguay | B. United States | C. West Germany | |
| . . . won a FIFA World Cup (women's soccer): A. Brazil | B. United States | C. Germany | |
| . . . earned a college degree: A. Carmelo Anthony | B. Joe Namath | C. Mia Hamm | |
| . . . played in an MLB All-Star game: A. Alex Rodriguez | B. Orlando Cabrera | C. Nomar Garciaparra | |
| . . . won an NBA Finals championship title: A. Hakeem Olajuwon | B. Larry Bird | C. Steve Nash | |
| . . . played for the football team at the University of Notre Dame: A. Tim Brown | B. Jay Cutler | C. Brady Quinn | |
| . . . won the Masters Tournament (golf): A. Ernie Els | B. Vijay Singh | C. Arnold Palmer | |
| . . . won the NCAA Division I Basketball Championship (men's): A. Texas Western | B. Ohio | C. Utah | |
| . . . won the NCAA Division I Basketball Championship (women's): A. Notre Dame | B. Purdue | C. Duke | |
| . . . won a World Series: A. New York Yankees | B. New York Mets | C. Seattle Mariners | |