| Hint | Missing Word |
| 1985: 'Careless ________' (Wham! ft. George Michael) | |
| 1987: 'Livin' on a ________' (Bon Jovi) | |
| 1989: '________ Up' (Paula Abdul) | |
| 1991: 'Gonna Make You ________ (Everybody Dance Now)' (C+C Music Factory ft. Freedom Williams) | |
| 1992: 'I Will Always ________ You' (Whitney Houston) | |
| 1996: 'One ________ Day' (Mariah Carey & Boyz II Men) | |
| 1999: 'Angel of ________' (Monica) | |
| 2002: 'U Got It ________' (Usher) | |
| 2009: 'My Life Would ________ Without You' (Kelly Clarkson) | |
| 2013: '________ Shop' (Macklemore & Ryan Lewis ft. Wanz) | |