| Hint | Character |
| Had a dog named Sir Scratchewan who 'miraculously' transformed into a tortoise | |
| Went on a two-minute date with a busy love interest | |
| The only member of the group for whom the Naked Man seduction strategy failed | |
| Believed father to be Bob Barker | |
| Original singer of the hit single 'Let's Go To The Mall' | |
| Developed a hot/crazy scale to judge members of the opposite sex | |
| May or may not have been mugged by a monkey | |
| Planned to join the Peace Corps with first serious significant other- that is, until betrayed | |
| Dated (and cheated on) a baker | |
| Accepts the offer to go on a date with Don Frank while posing as the person Don was actually asking out | |
| The slap bet commissioner for the Slapsgiving series | |
| Born and raised in St. Cloud, Minnesota | |
| Thought 'Cook Poo' was a made-up name and offended her multiple times | |
| Graduated from Columbia Law School | |
| Has only been in a relationship with one person . . . ever | |
| Was misnamed 'Swarley' by Chloe the coffee barista | |
| Punched a goat in the face | |
| Developed a hot/crazy scale to judge members of the opposite sex | |
| Original singer of the hit single 'Let's Go To The Mall' | |
| Had to get a butterfly 'tramp stamp' tattoo removed | |
| Is the originator of 'Suit up' and 'Legen- wait for it-dary' | |
| Has the middle name 'Evelyn' | |
| Dated (and cheated on) a baker | |
| Temporarily escaped engagement via a painting fellowship in San Francisco | |
| Has a doppelgänger who is a stripper | |
| Went on a two-minute date with a busy love interest | |
| Went on the Super Date due to a last minute change of plans | |
| Has the middle name 'Charles' | |
| Had a dog named Sir Scratchewan who 'miraculously' transformed into a tortoise | |
| Became distant with father, who declared he 'had no son,' after being caught kissing a male hockey teammate | |
| The only member of the group for whom the Naked Man seduction strategy failed | |
| Turned down a job offer in Chicago for a relationship, then got dumped by the significant other taking that same job | |
| Accepts the offer to go on a date with Don Frank while posing as the person Don was actually asking out | |
| Was the first person whose name was introduced in the series | |
| Tends to pass out whenever church bells are heard | |
| May or may not have been mugged by a monkey | |
| Believed father to be Bob Barker | |
| Creator of 'The Bro Code' and 'The Playbook' | |
| Planned to join the Peace Corps with first serious significant other- that is, until betrayed | |
| Voiced great disapproval on own birthday for the 'random skanks' brought to events by a friend | |