| Clue | Name |
| Former Sunnydale High Cheerleader | |
| Who Was the Center of Popularity Group | |
| Who Included the Future Vampire | |
| Who Dated Fellow Vampire | |
| Who Developed a Relationship With the Slayer | |
| Who Defeated the Head Vampire | |
| Who Had Two Minions, Luke and | |
| Who Sired | |
| Who Killed the Gypsie Descendant | |
| Who Dated Watcher | |
| | Clue | Name |
| Who Owned a Local Store Called the | |
| Who Held Meetings of the | |
| Which Included Former Vengeance Demon | |
| Who Was Friends With Fellow Vengeance Demon | |
| Who Helped Children Like Scooby Gang Member | |
| Who Had Milkshake-Movie Nights With the Witch | |
| Who Sensed that Buffy's Body was Stolen by Fellow Slayer | |
| Who Slept With Scooby Gang Member | |
| Who Dated the May Queen | |
|