| Hint | Character |
| Recently tried role playing | |
| Once played with a talking bear toy | |
| Is a Virgo | |
| Had surgery to repair a detached retina | |
| Bert's owner | |
| Hobbies include cooking, singing, reading | |
| Gives a blind girl a candy bar | |
| A military brat | |
| Has diabetes mellitus | |
| 'merchant of death' | |
| An expert on Middle Eastern terrorists | |
| Can't point with his right hand | |
| Convinced by Abby to get a tatoo | |
| Was shot in the stomach by Gibbs | |
| Trained by Gibbs (before Dinozzo) | |