| Year/School/Position | Player | Overall Pick |
| 2013 - Central Michigan - OT | |
| 2013 - BYU - DE | |
| 2013 - Houston - CB | |
| 2012 - Memphis - DT | |
| 2012 - Boise State - DE | |
| 2012 - Boise State - RB | |
| 2011 - Temple - DT/DE | |
| 2010 - Fresno State - RB | |
| 2010 - Idaho - OG | |
| 2010 - Boise State - CB | |
| 2010 - TCU - DE | |
| 2009 - Northern Illinois - DE/LB | |
| 2008 - Troy - CB | |
| 2008 - Boise State - OT | |
| 2008 - Tennessee State - CB | |
| 2008 - Delaware - QB | |
| 2008 - East Carolina - RB | |
| 2007 - Central Michigan - OT | |
| 2006 - Memphis - RB | |
| | Year/School/Position | Player | Overall Pick |
| 2005 - Utah - QB | |
| 2005 - Troy - LB | |
| 2005 - UAB - WR | |
| 2005 - Fresno State - OT | |
| 2004 - Miami (OH) - QB | |
| 2004 - Tulane - QB | |
| 2004 - Western Michigan - DE | |
| 2003 - Marshall - QB | |
| 2003 - Utah - OT | |
| 2002 - Fresno State - QB | |
| 2002 - Hawaii - WR | |
| 2002 - UAB - DE | |
| 2002 - Tulane - QB | |
| 2001 - TCU - RB | |
| 2000 - New Mexico - LB | |
| 2000 - Marshall - QB | |
| 2000 - Jackson State - WR | |
| 2000 - Jackson State - DB | |
| 2000 - BYU - LB | |
|