| Clue 1 | Player | Clue 2 |
| Dave N - Has more homers than any other MLB player born in Australia | |
| Dave O - Also known as Big Papi | |
| Dave P - Also known as The Cobra | |
| Dave Q - No such player | |
| Dave R - Helped spark Red Sox ALCS comeback vs. Yankees in 04 | |
| Dave S - Nicknamed smoke. Led 88 - 90 A's to the World Series | |
| Dave T - Pitched from 93 to 95 with the Mets | |
| Dave U - No such player | |
| Dave V - C for the Mariners from 84 - 93 | |
| Dave W - This Dave is in the HOF | |
| Dave X - No such player | |
| Dave Y - No such player | |
| Dave Z - Played from 1896 - 1905 | |
| Dave C - Fastest White Man in Glasses | |
| Dave R- Pitched a no-no with the Yankees | |
| Dave M - Utility man/Steroid user...did it help? | |
| Dave M - Long-time Orioles pitcher | |
| Dave C - Straight Money | |
| Dave S - The One-Hit Wonder (had lots of almost no-hitters) | |
| Dave D - Pitching Coach extraordinaire | |
| Dave V - A name only a Reds fan could love | |