| Clue | Name |
| 12) The Italian boyfriend | |
| 13) The identical twin of one of the main characters | |
| 14) The half brother who likes to melt things | |
| 15) The one who says 'oh my god' in a really annoying voice | |
| 16) The one who didn't know she was having twins | |
| 17) The boyfriend who had a drinking problem but was no fun without it | |
| 18) The one number 4 sleeps with when he is on a break | |
| 19) The gay ex-wife | |
| 20) Number 1s senior prom date | |
| 21) The student who dates her professor (number 4) | |
| 22) The one who changes his name to Crap Bag | |