| Team(s) | Player | Number of All-Star Seasons |
| SDP | |
| PIT, SFG | |
| NYM, LAD | |
| ATL | |
| MON | |
| CHC | |
| MON, FLA, HOU, CHC, SFG | |
| MON, CHC | |
| HOU, NYM | |
| ARI | |
| LAD, STL | |
| ATL | |
| FLA, LAD, ATL | |
| MON, COL | |
| COL | |
| MON | |
| COL, STL | |
| STL | |
| PIT, CIN | |
| HOU | |
| PIT, NYM | |
| MIL | |
| PHI | |
| STL | |
| CIN | |
| MIL, HOU | |
| WSN, CHC | |
| PIT | |
| PHI | |
| LAD | |
| PIT | |
| FLA | |
| STL | |
| FLA | |
| HOU | |
| | Team(s) | Player | Number of All-Star Seasons |
| CIN | |
| SFG | |
| CHC | |
| SDP, ARI | |
| ATL, CIN | |
| PIT | |
| MON | |
| MIL | |
| STL | |
| ATL | |
| SFG | |
| STL | |
| HOU | |
| CHC | |
| HOU | |
| COL | |
| MIL | |
| LAD | |
| CHC | |
| MON | |
| CIN | |
| PIT | |
| LAD | |
| FLA | |
| CIN | |
| CHC | |
| LAD | |
| CIN | |
| COL | |
| COL | |
| PHI | |
| ATL | |
| PHI | |
| MIL | |
| NYM | |
| | Team(s) | Player | Number of All-Star Seasons |
| SDP | |
| ATL | |
| STL | |
| CIN | |
| CHC | |
| STL | |
| SFG | |
| ATL | |
| STL | |
| LAD | |
| PIT | |
| LAD | |
| HOU | |
| CIN | |
| CHC | |
| HOU | |
| CIN | |
| MON | |
| PHI | |
| CIN | |
| STL | |
| LAD | |
| ARI | |
| SDP | |
| PHI | |
| PHI | |
| PHI | |
| COL | |
| ATL | |
| ARI | |
| SDP | |
| SDP | |
| ARI | |
| NYM | |
|