| Year/Team | Player | 2B, 3B, HR |
| 1901 CIN | |
| 1911 CHC | |
| 1920 SLB | |
| 1921 NYY | |
| 1921 NYY | |
| 1921 STL | |
| 1922 NYG | |
| 1925 PIT | |
| 1925 WSH | |
| 1926 WSH | |
| 1926 NYY | |
| 1927 NYY | |
| 1927 STL | |
| 1928 STL | |
| 1929 DET | |
| 1929 PIT | |
| 1930 CHW | |
| 1930 DET | |
| 1930 NYG | |
| 1930 NYY | |
| 1930 PHA | |
| 1931 BRO | |
| 1931 NYY | |
| 1932 CIN | |
| 1932 PHI | |
| 1932 NYY | |
| 1934 STL | |
| 1935 DET | |
| | Year/Team | Player | 2B, 3B, HR |
| 1936 CLE | |
| 1936 NYY | |
| 1937 NYY | |
| 1938 CLE | |
| 1938 STL | |
| 1940 NYY | |
| 1941 CLE | |
| 1944 NYY | |
| 1946 STL | |
| 1948 STL | |
| 1954 CHW | |
| 1957 NYG | |
| 1965 PHI | |
| 1977 BOS | |
| 1978 BOS | |
| 1979 KCR | |
| 1984 CHC | |
| 1984 PHI | |
| 1984 TOR | |
| 1987 PHI | |
| 1988 PIT | |
| 2005 TBD | |
| 2006 TBD | |
| 2006 NYM | |
| 2007 DET | |
| 2007 PHI | |
| 2008 NYM | |
|