| Year | Player | 1st pick that year: |
| 1990 (RB) | |
| 1991 (DB) | |
| 1992 (LB) | |
| 1993 (QB) | |
| 1994 (RB) | |
| 1995 (T) | |
| 1996 (LB) | |
| 1997 (DT) | |
| 1998 (QB) | |
| 1999 (QB) | |
| | Year | Player | 1st pick that year: |
| 2000 (LB) | |
| 2001 (T) | |
| 2002 (DE) | |
| 2003 (WR) | |
| 2004 (T) | |
| 2005 (RB) | |
| 2006 (RB) | |
| 2007 (WR) | |
| 2008 (DE) | |
| 2009 (OT) | |
| Bonus: 1936 (1st Draft) #2 overall | |
|