| Does this Help? | Nominees | Year |
| Would go on to win Rocket Richard trophy | |
| Also a little league world series winner | |
| Caused a calder winner to see a whole lot less/back-to-back Stanley Cup loser for two different teams | |
| All time leading scorer for his current and only franchise | |
| Signed by the Lightning to mentor rookie Victor Hedman | |
| Won the calder while on same team as another rookie who would go on to win the Hart trophy | |
| Was on explosive line with Joe Sakic and Simon Gagne during Canada's 2002 Gold Medal Olympic run | |
| Nicknamed 'Soup', career didn't amount to much | |
| First overall pick of the Senators/can't see too wel | |
| Involved in a deal that would send a former Calder winner to the Panthers | |
| Part of a dominating line in Canada's capital city | |
| Was the draft pick that was acquired for Dominik Hasek | |
| Shares his name with a famous comedian who also wears a mask | |
| Would later win the Hart trophy | |
| Once played on a line with Joe Sakic and Teemu Selanne | |
| Scored OT Stanley Cup game winner for New Jersey | |
| Part of the 'Legion of Doom' line with Eric Lindros and John LeClair | |
| His lone team has made the playoffs 18 of the 19 years he's played | |
| Trade from the Leafs to the Islander for a future Calder winner | |
| Scored over 100 points in rookie year playing with Cam Neely and Adam Oates | |
| Threw his glove in the air and 'shot ' it with his stick following a big goal in his rookie year | |
| Little brother married D.J. Tanner from 'Full House' | |
| Was part of a deal that was supposed to send Lindros to the Rangers | |
| Went on to win many Norris trophies | |
| Father with same name also played in the NHL | |
| Dated a famous female tennis star | |
| Also won the Vezina trophy this year | |
| Patrick Roy couldn't hear him because of his two Stanley Cup rings plugged in his ears | |
| His win sparked the league to change the rule for potential Calder winners | |
| Whole career spent with one franchise in two cities | |