| Election | Higher (H) or Lower (L) |
| 1789 & 1792 - Washington | |
| 1796 - Adams | |
| 1800 - Jefferson | |
| 1804 - Jefferson | |
| 1808 - Madison | |
| 1812 - Madison | |
| 1816 - Monroe | |
| 1820 - Monroe | |
| 1824 - Quincy Adams | |
| 1828 - Jackson | |
| 1832 - Jackson | |
| 1836 - Van Buren | |
| 1840 - Harrison | |
| 1844 - Polk | |
| 1848 - Taylor | |
| 1852 - Pierce | |
| 1856 - Buchanan | |
| 1860 - Lincoln | |
| 1864 - Lincoln | |
| 1868 - Grant | |
| 1872 - Grant | |
| 1876 - Hayes | |
| 1880 - Garfield | |
| 1884 - Cleveland | |
| 1888 - Harrison | |
| 1892 - Cleveland | |
| 1896 - McKinley | |
| 1900 - McKinley | |
| | Election | Higher (H) or Lower (L) |
| 1904 - Roosevelt | |
| 1908 - Taft | |
| 1912 - Wilson | |
| 1916 - Wilson | |
| 1920 - Harding | |
| 1924 - Coolidge | |
| 1928 - Hoover | |
| 1932 - Roosevelt | |
| 1936 - Roosevelt | |
| 1940 - Roosevelt | |
| 1944 - Roosevelt | |
| 1948 - Truman | |
| 1952 - Eisenhower | |
| 1956 - Eisenhower | |
| 1960 - Kennedy | |
| 1964 - Johnson | |
| 1968 - Nixon | |
| 1972 - Nixon | |
| 1976 - Carter | |
| 1980 - Reagan | |
| 1984 - Reagan | |
| 1988 - Bush | |
| 1992 - Clinton | |
| 1996 - Clinton | |
| 2000 - Bush | |
| 2004 - Bush | |
| 2008 - Obama | |
| 1796 - Adams | |
| 1800 - Jefferson | |
| 1804 - Jefferson | |
| 1808 - Madison | |
| 1812 - Madison | |
| 1816 - Monroe | |
| 1820 - Monroe | |
| 1824 - Quincy Adams | |
| 1828 - Jackson | |
| 1832 - Jackson | |
| 1836 - Van Buren | |
| 1840 - Harrison | |
| 1844 - Polk | |
| 1848 - Taylor | |
| 1852 - Pierce | |
| 1856 - Buchanan | |
| 1860 - Lincoln | |
| 1864 - Lincoln | |
| 1868 - Grant | |
| 1872 - Grant | |
| 1876 - Hayes | |
| 1880 - Garfield | |
| 1884 - Cleveland | |
| 1888 - Harrison | |
| 1892 - Cleveland | |
| 1896 - McKinley | |
| 1900 - McKinley | |
| 1904 - Roosevelt | |
| 1908 - Taft | |
| 1912 - Wilson | |
| 1916 - Wilson | |
| 1920 - Harding | |
| 1924 - Coolidge | |
| 1928 - Hoover | |
| 1932 - Roosevelt | |
| 1936 - Roosevelt | |
| 1940 - Roosevelt | |
| 1944 - Roosevelt | |
| 1948 - Truman | |
| 1952 - Eisenhower | |
| 1956 - Eisenhower | |
| 1960 - Kennedy | |
| 1964 - Johnson | |
| 1968 - Nixon | |
| 1972 - Nixon | |
| 1976 - Carter | |
| 1980 - Reagan | |
| 1984 - Reagan | |
| 1988 - Bush | |
| 1992 - Clinton | |
| 1996 - Clinton | |
| 2000 - Bush | |
| 2004 - Bush | |
| 2008 - Obama | |
|