| Hint | Name | Letter |
| MLBer who holds record for most career RBI and total bases | |
| Legendary Royals 3B | |
| All-time highest career batting average | |
| Famous Cowboys RB, won Heisman Trophy in 1976 | |
| Current Golden State Warriors guard | |
| 'He did what?!?', former Packers WR | |
| 2002 NFL MVP | |
| New Philadelphia Phillies' ace | |
| Michigan State basketball coach since 1995 | |
| Former NASCAR driver, won Winston Cup in '99 | |
| 5 time NBA Champion, all time leader in 3 point FG% | |
| Former boxer, aka 'The Raging Bull' | |
| New Orleans Saints all time leading rusher | |
| | Hint | Name | Letter |
| 'No Good! Wide Right!', infamous kicker | |
| Only defenseman to ever win scoring title (NHL) | |
| QB Drafted 18th overall by the Jets in 2000 NFL Draft | |
| Cleveland Browns QB | |
| 2003 Men's US Open Champion (tennis) | |
| Once suspended 68 games for choking his coach | |
| Current Dallas Mavericks guard | |
| Famous German road bicycle racer, won Tour de France in 1997 | |
| Cincinnati Reds 1B, hails from Canada | |
| World's #1 ranked golfer, currently on hiatus | |
| Hall of Fame Los Angeles Rams DE, 7 time Pro Bowl selection | |
| Former MLB player and manager, well known for altercation with Pedro Martinez | |
|