| This is the stupidest quiz ever. Sandy Koufax is the greatest pitcher that I've ever seen pitch. He was unanimously voted the best pitcher in Baseball (Cy Young when only 1 was given out) 3 of his last 4 years. If he's overrated, then so are Carlton, Seaver, Gibson, Palmer, Maddux, Johnson, Clemens, Martinez, ect because none of them are in his class. As far as his underrated list, it's a joke. Feller, Ruth, Berra, Musial, Robinson. These guys are all rated among the top 2-3 players at their position all time. Greenberg and Snider aren't far behind. Snider was considered in the same class as Mays and Mantle when they played. Ruth only pitched 3 full seasons and he was great, but somehow he is underrated and the guy who put together the greatest 5 year span in history is overrated? As far as Koufax's early record, if Jayson Stark wasn't an idiot, he would have known that Koufax couldn't pitch in the minors or the Dodgers would have lost him to another team like they did with Roberto Clemente. It would help if Stark knew anything about Baseball history, but he obviously doen't from this list. |