| Series | Player | Pitcher |
| 1949 WS | |
| 1954 WS | |
| 1957 WS | |
| 1960 WS | |
| 1964 WS | |
| 1973 NLCS | |
| 1973 ALCS | |
| 1975 WS | |
| 1976 ALCS | |
| 1979 ALCS | |
| 1981 NLDS | |
| 1981 NLDS | |
| 1984 NLCS | |
| 1985 NLCS | |
| 1986 NLCS | |
| 1988 WS | |
| 1988 WS | |
| 1991 WS | |
| 1993 WS | |
| 1995 ALDS | |
| 1995 ALDS | |
| | Series | Player | Pitcher |
| 1996 ALCS | |
| 1999 NLDS | |
| 1999 ALCS | |
| 1999 WS | |
| 2000 NLDS | |
| 2001 ALCS | |
| 2001 WS | |
| 2003 ALDS | |
| 2003 ALCS | |
| 2003 WS | |
| 2004 NLDS | |
| 2004 ALDS | |
| 2004 ALCS | |
| 2004 NLCS | |
| 2004 NLCS | |
| 2005 NLDS | |
| 2005 WS | |
| 2006 ALCS | |
| 2007 ALDS | |
| 2009 ALDS | |
| 1999 NLCS | |
| 1978 AL East Tiebreaker | |
| 1951 NL Tiebreaker | |
|