| Hint | Manager | Team |
| Former Rookie of The Year; played 16 seasons as a slick-fielding, weak hitting shortstop, mostly for the White Sox | |
| Played OF for the Twins and Dodgers 1969-1975, career .198 batting average | |
| Played 87 games at OF and 1B for the Cubs in the early 80s | |
| Caught for the Dodgers for 13 seasons between 1980 and 1992 | |
| Played 106 games, mostly at 3B, for the Expos in the early 80s | |
| Gold-glove winning C mostly for St. Louis and Milwaukee in the 90s and 00s | |
| Backup C for the Brewers, Rangers and Expos in the early 80s | |
| Caught for 9 seasons between 1978 and 1987 with the Astros, Mets and Padres | |
| Caught 4 seasons in the Angels organization in the late 70s; never made it above A-ball | |
| Utility infielder; played 10 seasons for 5 teams, mostly the Twins 1977-1989 | |
| Spent most of his career as a backup catcher for the Yankees, Rockies and Cubs from 1989-2003 | |
| Gold-glove winning 3B who spent most of his career with the White Sox in the 90s, hit 294 home runs | |
| An original Rockie who caught 39 games for the Red Sox and Rockies in the early 90s | |
| 2B for the Orioles and Braves in the 60s and 70s, belted 43 HR in 1973 | |
| Former outfielder collected 1,981 hits over a 19-season career, mostly with the Dodgers and Braves | |
| | Hint | Manager | Team |
| Utility infielder with the Pirates and Dodgers organizations in the 70s, never made the majors | |
| Spent 7 seasons in the Yankees organization as a 1B/OF from 1977-1983; never played in the majors | |
| Caught for 7 seasons in the Tigers organization in the 60s and early 70s, never made the majors | |
| Won 121 games in the 80s and early 90s with 5 different teams, mostly the Royals | |
| Slick-fielding SS, played 12 seasons mostly for Brewers and Pirates in the 80s and 90s | |
| Played 5 seasons in the late 80s and early 90s in the Astros organization, mostly at 3B, never made the majors | |
| SP who won most of his 36 games with the Indians in the late 80s with stops in California and Detroit in the early 90s | |
| Utility infielder for the Mets in the early 80s; not much of a bat | |
| Minor league C with the Yankees in the 80s, never made it above AA | |
| Played OF for six teams, mostly Dodgers and Phillies, over 8 seasons in the 80s | |
| OF who spent 10 seasons with the Royals and Mets in the 70s and 80s | |
| Utility player for the Mets, Dodgers, Padres and Angels in the 70's, played every position except P over his 10 seasons | |
| Slick-fielding, MVP-winning 1B for the Yankees | |
| This MVP-winning World Series hero hit 255 home runs in his 17 year career, mostly with the Tigers | |
| Spent 10 seasons as backup C, mostly for the Giants and Orioles in the 80s and 90s | |
|