| Clue | Player | HR |
| A player who slugged under .500 | |
| A player with fewer than 100 RBI | |
| A player who struck out fewer than 50 times | |
| A player listed as weighing under 150 pounds | |
| A player who is active as of 2010 | |
| A player who is the only person in MLB history with his first name | |
| A player born in New York City | |
| A player born in Los Angeles | |
| A player born in Chicago | |
| A player who went to an Ivy League college | |
| A player who played all 9 positions in that season (not counting DH) | |
| A DH | |
| A player in his first MLB season | |
| A player in his last MLB season | |
| A player during World War II (1943-1945) | |
| A player whose last name ends in two consecutive vowels | |
| A player whose last name ends in the same two consonants in a row | |
| A player whose last name ends in '-ski' | |
| A player who did it in the 1800s | |
| A player born in Asia | |
| A player with the letters S-P-O-R-C-L-E in his name | |