| Year & Team | Player Name | Stats (Rank in Parentheses) |
| 2010 CIN | |
| 2010 DET | |
| 2009 STL | |
| 2006 STL | |
| 2005 STL | |
| 1998 CHW | |
| 1997 COL | |
| 1995 COL | |
| 1994 CHW | |
| 1994 CLE | |
| 1994 HOU | |
| 1978 BOS | |
| 1978 PIT | |
| 1972 CHC | |
| 1972 CHW | |
| 1967 BOS* | |
| 1966 BAL* | |
| 1965 SF | |
| 1963 MLN | |
| 1962 CIN | |
| 1959 MLN | |
| 1956 NYY* | |
| 1955 NYG | |
| 1953 CLE | |
| 1949 BOS | |
| | Year & Team | Player Name | Stats (Rank in Parentheses) |
| 1949 STL | |
| 1948 STL | |
| 1947 BOS* | |
| 1946 BOS | |
| 1945 BSN | |
| 1942 BOS* | |
| 1939 STL | |
| 1938 BOS | |
| 1937 NYY | |
| 1937 NYY | |
| 1937 STL* | |
| 1935 PHA | |
| 1934 NYY* | |
| 1933 NYY | |
| 1933 PHA* | |
| 1933 PHI* | |
| 1932 PHA | |
| 1932 PHI | |
| 1930 NYY | |
| 1930 PHI | |
| 1929 CHC | |
| 1929 PHA | |
| 1928 NYY | |
| 1927 NYG | |
| 1927 NYY | |
| | Year & Team | Player Name | Stats (Rank in Parentheses) |
| 1926 NYY | |
| 1925 STL* | |
| 1924 NYY | |
| 1923 DET | |
| 1923 NYY | |
| 1922 STL* | |
| 1921 NYY | |
| 1921 STL | |
| 1920 SLB | |
| 1918 PHA | |
| 1913 PHI | |
| 1912 CHC | |
| 1911 DET | |
| 1910 DET | |
| 1909 DET* | |
| 1908 DET | |
| 1908 PIT | |
| 1907 DET | |
| 1905 CIN | |
| 1902 BOS-CLE | |
| 1901 BOS | |
| 1901 BRO | |
| 1901 PHA* | |
| 1914 Fed. Lg. | |
|