| Years Played with Yankees | Player | Elected as... |
| 1916-1922 | |
| 1946-1963 | |
| 1993-1997 | |
| 1901-1902 | |
| 1913-1914 | |
| 1903-1909 | |
| 1924-1935 | |
| 1928 | |
| 1928-1946 | |
| 1936-1951 | |
| 1925-1929 | |
| 1950-1967 | |
| 1923-1939 | |
| 1930-1942 | |
| 1938-1946 | |
| 1978-1983, 1989 | |
| 1903-1907 | |
| 1934 | |
| 1985-1989 | |
| 1921-1930 | |
| 1975-1979 | |
| | Years Played with Yankees | Player | Elected as... |
| 1977-1981 | |
| 1903-1909 | |
| 1926-1937 | |
| 1951-1968 | |
| 1901-1902 | |
| 1901-1902 | |
| 1913 | |
| 1949-1953 | |
| 1984-1985 | |
| 1923-1933 | |
| 1980 | |
| 1907 | |
| 1941-1956 | |
| 1901-1902 | |
| 1930-1946 | |
| 1920-1934 | |
| 1931-1933 | |
| 1954-1959 | |
| 1915-1918 | |
| 1944-1945 | |
| 1981-1990 | |
| 1964, 1984-1985 (Manager) | |
| 1913-1914 (Manager) | |
| 1946 (Manager) | |
| 1903-1908 (Manager) | |
| 1946-1948 (Manager) | |
| 1918-1929 (Manager) | |
| 1978-1979, 1981-1982 (Manager) | |
| 1931-1946 (Manager) | |
| 1901-1902 (Manager) | |
| 1902 (Manager) | |
| 1949-1960 (Manager) | |
|