| Years Played with Reds | Player | Elected as... |
| 1897-1903 | |
| 1967-1983 | |
| 1933-1935 | |
| 1913 | |
| 1892-1894 | |
| 1899-1902 | |
| 1935-1937 | |
| 1930-1933 | |
| 1895-1897 | |
| 1909-1910 | |
| 1932-1937 | |
| 1918 | |
| 1932 | |
| 1904-1909 | |
| 1902-1906 | |
| 1927-1930 | |
| 1932-1941 | |
| | Years Played with Reds | Player | Elected as... |
| 1921 | |
| 1916 | |
| 1916-1917 | |
| 1882-1899 | |
| 1972-1979 | |
| 1964-1976, 1984-1986 | |
| 1891 | |
| 1921-1933 | |
| 1956-1965 | |
| 1916-1926, 1931 | |
| 1901 | |
| 1977-1982 | |
| 1913 | |
| 1939 | |
| 1934 | |
| 1941 | |
| 1970-1978 (Manager) | |
| 1892-1894 (Manager) | |
| 1895-1899 (Manager) | |
| 1909-1911 (Manager) | |
| 1906-1907 (Manager) | |
| 1952-1953 (Manager) | |
| 1902-1905 (Manager) | |
| 1916-1918 (Manager) | |
| 1938-1946 (Manager) | |
| 1901-1902 (Manager) | |
| 1993 (Manager) | |
| 1913 (Manager) | |
| 1937 (Manager) | |
| 1963-1978, 1984-1986 | |
|