| Description | Answer |
| Hall of Fame Miami Dolphins quarterback that never won a Super Bowl | |
| Former Harlem Globetrotter who holds NBA scoring and rebound records, despite have one of the worst free throw percentages | |
| Shortstop and third baseman who was offered the largest contract in baseball history in 2000, but later became 'cooler' and tested positive for steroids | |
| Two-time MVP and Super Bowl winning quarterback that retired after the 2009 season | |
| Hall of Fame right fielder wore number 13 in his rookie season with the Pittsburgh Pirates before dying tragically in 1972 | |
| Famous Toronto Maple Leafs team captain who ended his career with injuries and criticism with the Vancouver Canucks | |
| Dallas Maverick and Phoenix Sun point guard whose reality show idea was stolen by Shaq | |
| | Description | Answer |
| Intelligent racehorse that started in the number 13 lane that won the Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes, but lost to a long shot in the Belmont Stakes | |
| AFL wide receiver who won Super Bowl III with the New York Jets, even though he was a 'NFL Reject' | |
| Mad NASCAR driver given the number 13 Geico Toyota car in 2009. Oh great, Toyota! | |
| Former Charlotte Hornet shooting guard who had his jersey retired after dying in a car accident in 2000 | |
| Captain of the German national soccer team and one of the top scorers of all time, but couldn't amount a goal in a 1-0 lost to Spain in the UFEA Euro 2008 Championship | |
| Right wing member of the 1980 U.S. Hockey Team who wore 13 with the Winnipeg Jets and was inducted into the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame in 2001. Nothing really bad to say here | |
|