| position (years) | player | WAR |
| 2B (1902-14) | |
| OF (1916-26) | |
| P (1936-41, 45-56) | |
| SS (1938-52) | |
| 1B/3B (1991-02) | |
| P (1916-24) | |
| OF (1992-96, 98-01, 07) | |
| OF (1929-39) | |
| P (1928-47) | |
| P (1946-58) | |
| OF (1947-55, 58) | |
| P (1902-10) | |
| SS (1920-30) | |
| P (1961-71) | |
| P (1949-57, 63) | |
| OF (1910-15) | |
| P (1948-59) | |
| 3B (1947-56) | |
| 3B (1901-1910) | |
| OF (1902-1910) | |
| SS/3B (1904-1918) | |
| SS (1994-04) | |
| 3B (1937-44, 46-49) | |
| P (1926-40) | |
| OF (1993-00) | |
| P (2001-08) | |
| 2B (1949-58) | |
| OF (2004-present) | |
| | position (years) | player | WAR |
| P (1972-75) | |
| SS (1912-20) | |
| 1B (1933-41) | |
| OF (1989-96) | |
| P (1927-33) | |
| OF (1955-59, 65-67) | |
| P (1916-22) | |
| P (1919-28, 36) | |
| P (1964-69) | |
| OF (1936-45) | |
| P (1990-02) | |
| 3B (1972-78) | |
| OF (1919-32) | |
| 2B (1999-01) | |
| C (2002-09) | |
| P (1997-02) | |
| P (1986-91, 99) | |
| DH (2003-present) | |
| SS/2B/OF (1958-64) | |
| P (1936-40) | |
| 1B/DH (1977-79, 81-87) | |
| P (1911-14) | |
| 2B (1947-50) | |
| OF (1946-56) | |
| P (1981-85) | |
| C (1911-23) | |
| P (1964-69) | |
| 3B (1979-83) | |
| | position (years) | player | WAR |
| P (2002-09) | |
| 2B (1991-96) | |
| C (1960-64) | |
| OF (1984-87) | |
| P (1986-91, 96) | |
| 3B (1984-92) | |
| SS/3B (2003-present) | |
| P (1914-24) | |
| 3B (1970-72) | |
| SS/2B (1983-88, 96-97) | |
| OF (1930-36) | |
| P (1941-53) | |
| 2B/3B (1931, 33-40) | |
| 1B (1979-85) | |
| P (1955-59) | |
| OF (1984-89) | |
| P (1975-83) | |
| OF (2006-present) | |
| OF (1908, 10-22) | |
| 1B/OF (1928-33) | |
| 3B/OF/1B (2003-08) | |
| P (1924-31) | |
| P (1975-77) | |
| C (1990-00) | |
| OF (1959-64) | |
| P (2001-present) | |
|