Can you name the quarterback who is best in each category? by chair

Can you name the quarterback who is best in each category?

created by chair

Enter a quarterback in the box below
Correctly named quarterbacks will show up below
Click any empty Which quarterback has... or Peyton, Eli, or a tie? to answer for that location
Some wrong answers will appear in red
Source: Pro Football Reference and NFL.com
The Manning brothers are both having excellent NFL careers. How do they compare against each other?
Also try: Quarterback Duel III: Bradshaw vs. Roethlisberger
Enter P for Peyton Manning and E for Eli Manning. If you think the statistic is equal, enter T for a tie. All categories regular season only unless noted otherwise. Data current through 2011 season.
This quiz has not been verified by Sporcle

Popular trivia games today

Cartoon Therapy

4911

Home Row Key Images

4061

Groups of Five

2241

Pandemic Logic Puzzle

2080

Billiard Ball Colors

1878

Word Ladder: Final Exam

1793

How'd They Meet: TV Couples Edition

1769

Missing Word: 'In' the Movies

1442

And more...

PLAY GAME

05:00

Show Missed Answers

Which quarterback has...	Peyton, Eli, or a tie?	Details
played more seasons?
started more games?		Eli has started 119 games.
more career passing touchdowns?		Eli has 185 career touchdowns.
more career interceptions?		Eli has 129 career interceptions.
a higher career passer rating?		Eli's career passer rating is 82.1.
more career passing yards?		Eli has passed for 27,579 yards.
more career rushing yards?		Eli has rushed for 365 yards.
more career rushing touchdowns?		Eli has rushed for 4 touchdowns.
been sacked more times (career)?		Eli has been sacked 194 times.
fumbled more times (career)?		Peyton has fumbled 57 times.
more passing touchdowns in a season?		Eli had 31 passing TDs in 2010.
more interceptions in a season?		Eli had 25 interceptions in 2010.
a higher passing rating in a season?		Eli had a rating of 92.9 in 2011.
more passing yards in a season?		Peyton threw for 4,700 yards in 2010.
more rushing yards in a season?		Eli ran for 80 yards in 2005.
more rushing touchdowns in a season?		Eli ran for 1 TD in 4 seasons.
thrown fewer interceptions in a season (having started at least one game)?
been sacked more times in a season?		Peyton was sacked 29 times in 2001.
been sacked fewer times in a season (having started at least one game)?		Eli was sacked 13 times in 2004.
fumbled more times in a season?		Peyton fumbled 7 times in 2001.
fumbled fewer times in a season (having started at least one game)?		Eli fumbled 3 times in 2004.
thrown more touchdowns in a single game?		Eli threw for 4 TDs in 6 games.
thrown more interceptions in a game?		Eli threw 4 interceptions in 3 games.
a higher passer rating in a game?
thrown for more yards in a game?		Eli threw for 420, 10/9/11, vs. SEA.
rushed for more yards in a game?		Eli ran for 34 yards, 11/1/09, @ PHI.
rushed for more touchdowns in a game?
been sacked more times in a game?		Peyton was sacked 5 times in 2 games.
fumbled more times in a game?		Peyton fumbled 3 times in 2 games.
won more games (as a starter)?		Eli has won 69 games.
started more postseason games?		Eli has started 11 postseason games.
won more postseason games (as a starter)?		Eli has won 8 postseason games.
been named NFL MVP more times?		Eli has not been named NFL MVP.
been named First-Team All-Pro more times?
played in more Super Bowls?		Peyton: XLI, XLIV; Eli: XLII, XLVI
won more Super Bowls?		Peyton won Super Bowl XLI.
been named Super Bowl MVP more times?		Peyton was MVP for Super Bowl XLI.
been selected to more Pro Bowls?		Eli has been selected to 2 Pro Bowls.
a higher draft pick?
played for more teams?
a higher jersey number?		Eli wears number 10.
played more seasons?	Eli wears number 10.
started more games?	Eli wears number 10.
more career passing touchdowns?	Eli wears number 10.
more career interceptions?	Eli wears number 10.
a higher career passer rating?	Eli wears number 10.
more career passing yards?	Eli wears number 10.
more career rushing yards?	Eli wears number 10.
more career rushing touchdowns?	Eli wears number 10.
been sacked more times (career)?	Eli wears number 10.
fumbled more times (career)?	Eli wears number 10.
more passing touchdowns in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
more interceptions in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
a higher passing rating in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
more passing yards in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
more rushing yards in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
more rushing touchdowns in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
thrown fewer interceptions in a season (having started at least one game)?	Eli wears number 10.
been sacked more times in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
been sacked fewer times in a season (having started at least one game)?	Eli wears number 10.
fumbled more times in a season?	Eli wears number 10.
fumbled fewer times in a season (having started at least one game)?	Eli wears number 10.
thrown more touchdowns in a single game?	Eli wears number 10.
thrown more interceptions in a game?	Eli wears number 10.
a higher passer rating in a game?	Eli wears number 10.
thrown for more yards in a game?	Eli wears number 10.
rushed for more yards in a game?	Eli wears number 10.
rushed for more touchdowns in a game?	Eli wears number 10.
been sacked more times in a game?	Eli wears number 10.
fumbled more times in a game?	Eli wears number 10.
won more games (as a starter)?	Eli wears number 10.
started more postseason games?	Eli wears number 10.
won more postseason games (as a starter)?	Eli wears number 10.
been named NFL MVP more times?	Eli wears number 10.
been named First-Team All-Pro more times?	Eli wears number 10.
played in more Super Bowls?	Eli wears number 10.
won more Super Bowls?	Eli wears number 10.
been named Super Bowl MVP more times?	Eli wears number 10.
been selected to more Pro Bowls?	Eli wears number 10.
a higher draft pick?	Eli wears number 10.
played for more teams?	Eli wears number 10.
a higher jersey number?	Eli wears number 10.

Javascript is not currently enabled on your browser.
If you do have Javascript enabled:
This site uses javascript to make the magic happen.
Please turn on javascript and reload this page, or use a more current browser (like Firefox)

You might also like these games:
MLB Teams	NFL Teams	NBA Teams

There are 3 comments for this game.
(Warning: comments may contain spoilers)

Quarterback Duel IV: Peyton vs. Eli Quiz

by chair

Created Feb 7, 2012 in Sports
Game Plays 115

Friend Scores and Standings

Loading friend results....

Top Games Today in Sports

Top Games with Similar Tags

Top User Games in Sports

	chair:	Feb 7th, 2012 at 05:05 GMT		1 point
	After gathering the data for this quiz, I realized how non-comparable the Manning Brothers actually are. Eli has done some great things, but Peyton is simply outstanding. Ah well. Up next will be Montana and Young. Also planning to do Brady and Bledsoe, maybe Kitna/Culpepper. That might be it, unless anyone has other suggestions. Is there someone I could compare Testaverde with?

	Quock:	Feb 7th, 2012 at 09:37 GMT		1 point
	At Chair. Thank you for realizing Peyton is far superior to Eli. The argument is ridiculous...and I'm not a Colts fan. How about Testaverde and Krieg?

	mlbnflwhiz:	Feb 10th, 2012 at 22:38 GMT		1 point
	The entire argument is off-base and pointless. In each given year so far, it is clear who was the better qb that year...Peyton 1998-2010, Eli 2011. Eli is the better postseason qb. Peyton has been the better regular season qb 12 of 13 years. Peyton's numbers are astronomically superior. BUT, in comparing Peyton's average stats post-Edgerrin James (2006-2010) to Eli this year, where both had to throw the ball a ton because of no running game, they are nearly identical. Eli threw for more yards than Peyton ever did, but lower completion %, and very similar TD/INT numbers. Eli, only one year into his true prime, hasn't had an Edgerrin James to make him better. So for now, only time will tell, and while Peyton will likely always have superior total numbers due to a shorter developement and longer prime, best in their prime is still up for grabs