| Clue | Athlete |
| Hall of famer Bruce was a reliever for the Cubs and Cardinals who popularized the splitter | |
| Lenny Dykstra's son, who's toiling in the minors for the Potomac Nationals | |
| Bears' quarterback Jay, obtained in 2009 from the Broncos | |
| Basketballers Rasaul, Caron and Da'Sean | |
| Northern Ireland BMW F3 racer William | |
| Captain Kirk played with the Devils 1984-91, won a Cup with Montreal, now coaches Carolina | |
| Joe was the first American-born player to score 500 NHL goals; or his brother, Brian | |
| 4-time Super Bowl winner Matt was president of the Lions from 2001-08 | |
| Bode is one of the USA's all-time great skiers | |
| First baseman turned analyst Kevin won a World Series with the 2004 Red Sox | |
| Felix played second base for the Braves and Mets in the 70s | |
| National Lacrosse Hall of Famer Mark runs the largest lacrosse camps in the USA | |
| Eric pitched in the Majors from 1998-2009, starting with the Twins | |
| White Sox Comcast broadcaster Bill, who hit homers and played 3rd base from 1968-77 | |
| Todd ranks first in games, hits, runs and homers for the Colorado Rockies | |
| Brian pitched in relief from 1985-90, winning the Series with the Dodgers | |
| Tim played defense for 25 years in the NHL, and founded a chain of Canadian doughnut shops | |
| Craig quarterbacked the Cowboys, Giants and Broncos from 1965-1982 | |
| Curt played mostly for the Orioles, once hitting consecutive pinch-hit home runs in 1969 | |
| Sir Henry won three British Open championships in the 30s and 40s | |
| Wrestler Scott currently goes by the name Colt Cabana | |
| Total obscurity time - Cecil's only 2 career hits were triples - an MLB record! | |
| Just like Reggie Cleveland never played for the Indians, Daryl never played for the Red Sox | |
| Maceo played over 100 NBA games with Toronto and Indiana from 2002-2009 | |
| P Chris had a short MLB career, C Dave had a short NBA career and RB Bobby had a short NFL career | |
| Figure skater Dick won Olympic gold in 1948 and 1952, and won an Emmy in 1981 for his analysis for ABC | |
| Hall of famer Don won 324 games and also holds the record for most career at-bats without a home run (1354) | |