| Seasons with the Leafs | Player |
|---|
| 21 (1949-1971) | |
| 20 (1949-1970) | |
| 16 (1973-1989) | |
| 16 (1963-1981) | |
| 15 (1960-1975) | |
| 14 (1956-1970) | |
| 14 (1956-1973) | |
| 14 (1942-1957) | |
| 14 (1936-1952) | |
| 13 (1994-2008) | |
| 13 (1952-1965) | |
| 13 (1985-2000) | |
| 13 (1965-1978) | |
| 13 (1956-1970) | |
| 12 (1998-2011) | |
| 12 (1970-1982) | |
| 12 (1989-2006) | |
| | Seasons with the Leafs | Player |
|---|
| 12 (1956-1968) | |
| 12 (1945-1957) | |
| 12 (1984-1996) | |
| 12 (1946-1958) | |
| 12 (1934-1948) | |
| 12 (1934-1946) | |
| 12 (1928-1940) | |
| 11 (1926-1937) | |
| 10 (1958-1968) | |
| 10 (1955-1965) | |
| 10 (1954-1964) | |
| 10 (1947-1958) | |
| 10 (1982-1992) | |
| 10 (1929-1939) | |
| 10 (1936-1948) | |
| 10 (1949-1960) | |
| 10 (1935-1945) | |
| 9 (1973-1982) | |
| 9 (1969-1978) | |
| 9 (1999-2009) | |
| 9 (1960-1975) | |
| 9 (1946-1955) | |
| 9 (2000-2010) | |
| 9 (1957-1980) | |
| 9 (1967-1978) | |
| 9 (1942-1956) | |
| 9 (1929-1938) | |
| 9 (1927-1936) | |
| 9 (1938-1949) | |
| 8 (1967-1975) | |
| 8 (1977-1985) | |
| 8 (1979-1987) | |
| 8 (1999-2008) | |
| 8 (1982-1990) | |
| 8 (1959-1967) | |
| 8 (1986-1994) | |
| 8 (1982-1990) | |
| 8 (1991-1999) | |
| 8 (1928-1936) | |
| 8 (1946-1954) | |
| 8 (1926-1934) | |
| 8 (1960-1968) | |
| 8 (1949-1957) | |
| 8 (1983-1991) | |
|
MLB Teams 
NBA Teams 
4-Sport Cities
